Photoclubalpha

Yildiz, I certainly didn't intend to hurt your feelings. I appreciate very much your feedback. As I have discovered after getting feedback from 48 people though is that generally everyone disagrees with each other. A few of the photos have gotten more votes to be eliminated, but the truth is no photo has gotten less than 4 votes to be eliminated. All of this has helped to think more clearly though and I will choose the 12 today. This is not for a calendar. Thank you!

bakubo wrote:Yildiz, I certainly didn't intend to hurt your feelings. I appreciate very much your feedback. As I have discovered after getting feedback from 48 people though is that generally everyone disagrees with each other. A few of the photos have gotten more votes to be eliminated, but the truth is no photo has gotten less than 4 votes to be eliminated. All of this has helped to think more clearly though and I will choose the 12 today. This is not for a calendar. Thank you!

Hello there!

Bakubo, you definitely did not hurt my feelings. Please feel free to do as you please and maybe someday we'll be able to see the finalized project too!
I just wished to let you know the path I took while going over the photos. It must be a naturally hard process to listen to others and make up your own mind.


Good luck!

Yildiz

Henry, just listen to your heart. And good luck, you need it.
Do let us know which you picked after all.

Okay, I am about to make a final choice of the 12 photos to burn onto a CD. I have been looking at #6 again. I have tried another crop:



Here is the crop Sonolta suggested:



Here is my original crop:



What do you think?

No doubt the first one, which includes the tree.

Dr. Harout wrote:No doubt the first one, which includes the tree.

Thanks, that is the one I decided to go with yesterday.

I want to thank everyone who replied to me and gave me their opinions on which 6 of the 18 photos I should eliminate. Thank you!

I promised several of you that I would get back to you and let you know which photos I ended up choosing. Also, what the vote count turned out to be. Yesterday afternoon I made my final decision and these are the photos I decided to use:

1, 2, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 12, 14, 16, 17, 18

These are the photos I eliminated:

3, 9, 10, 11, 13, 15

You can see all of the photos here:

http://s239.photobucket.com/albums/ff17 ... o/Help_Me/" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Okay, now for the vote. I received replies from 49 people and here are the votes for the photos to be eliminated:

01: 11111
02: 1111111111
03: 111111111111111111111111111
04: 1111111111111
05: 11111111111111
06: 111111111111
07: 11111111111
08: 11111111111111111111
09: 1111111111111111111111
10: 1111111111111111111111111111111
11: 111111
12: 1111111111111111111111111
13: 11111111111111111111111111111
14: 11111
15: 1111111111111111111
16: 11111111111
17: 11111111111
18: 1111111111

Note that a handful of people did not give me a full 6 selections for the photos to be eliminated so if you count all the votes up it won't come out perfect.

Thanks again to everyone!

I was 50/50 on this (golden medium, I would say ).
Congratulations for a hard choice making.

i don,t envy your task , theyre all good.

here is my fav 4, the reason i chose them was simply ,the pics told you where they were taken


14; 1; 15; 17 in that order

Thanks, gio67. I appreciate the input!