Photoclubalpha

Hi Everyone. Yildiz (aster) and I have had a bit of a discussion via PM (I sent her a PM asking the question). There is one final challenge we would like to run. It is a "Best photo submitted for a PCA challenge". This one, however, is a little different. You cannot nominate yourself, you nominate another members work that was submitted to a challenge, that you thought was outstanding.

The catch here is that the photos submitted in a challenge were not originally submitted to this particular challenge. Yildiz and I came to the understand that we should put a disclaimer in this forum, that if anyone here objects to their work being used for the "Photo of the year" challenge, that they should simply state that up front.

What does everyone think? Is this reasonable? Should we proceed? If folks think it's a good idea look for a thread starting soon.

Thanks again,
L

why not anybody submitting one of their own pics, posted during the year, and then we vote? up to 3 votes by member, hum?

pakodominguez wrote:why not anybody submitting one of their own pics, posted during the year, and then we vote? up to 3 votes by member, hum?

That would be the other challenge. What you personally think your best work was. This one would be a "by your peers", and what they thought was your best shot.

Hearing no real objections, shall we proceed?

Definitely yes. But that means going through all the pages in this forum...

Dr. Harout wrote:Definitely yes. But that means going through all the pages in this forum...

Well, then you better get on it...

Lonnie Utah wrote:
The catch here is that the photos submitted in a challenge were not originally submitted to this particular challenge.

L

I'm not sure I understand that, are you asking for pictures (taken by the respective photographer) that would have qualified for a certain challenge but were not entered in it?
What does the final statement - 'this particular challenge' - reference to? Sorry if I'm being spectacularly thick here but it's late Xmas day now and I have a warm fuzzy glow on.