I voted for the 2nd one.
But..this is going to depend on what camera you have. A100 is different to the A200, 350 seems a bit different to both, A700 again, not the same.
Also it's very hard to make a judgement on posted shots, WB is a huge factor..many do AWB, and it can be off and influence your judgement. Then raw, can look different depending on software used..and how it is used.
Jpeg wise, I think also makes things hard.
Maybe we should have had another option, "KM colours"

Whilst I get along ok with the A200, and I am pleased enough.. it's not in the same league as the 5d for tonality. Which in turn is not in the same league for real film (IMO of course)
Sony should have put a KM colour mode in there, when it works it really does shine, in a way that no Sony I have seen does.